Mesh vs. Solid Safety Pool Covers: Which is Best?

Mesh vs. Solid Safety Pool Covers Which is Best

When we talk about pool covers, we are essentially referring to a large, often custom-sized barrier that is placed over your swimming pool. Its primary purpose? To protect both the pool and those around it. Pool covers offer safety by preventing accidental falls into the pool, especially in households with children or pets.

On the protective front, a cover shields the pool from external elements such as leaves, debris, and harsh weather conditions. Lastly, by reducing evaporation and maintaining the pool’s temperature, a cover promotes energy and cost efficiency. Two main types of pool covers exist in the market today: mesh and solid safety pool covers.

Mesh Safety Pool Covers

At first glance, mesh pool covers may appear quite similar to a large net stretched across your pool. Lightweight and easy to handle, these covers are designed to allow water – rain or melted snow – to seep through into the pool while keeping larger debris out.

While they’re durable and require little maintenance, mesh covers are not perfect. One of the major downsides is that the water seeping through might carry smaller particles of dirt, which may make the pool appear less clear. The lightweight nature of the mesh pool cover makes it an ideal choice for owners who need to cover and uncover their pools frequently.

Solid Safety Pool Covers

In contrast to mesh pool covers, solid safety pool covers are more heavy-duty. Think of them as a solid barrier between your pool and the outside world, preventing any debris or sunlight from reaching the pool water. Due to their robust build, they keep the water much cleaner than mesh covers.

However, one caveat is that solid covers require a pump or a drainage system to remove the water that collects on top of the cover. If you live in an area that sees a lot of rainfall or if you don’t mind the extra maintenance, a solid cover might be right for you.

Comparing Mesh and Solid Safety Pool Covers

Comparing Mesh and Solid Safety Pool Covers

When it comes to durability, both mesh and solid pool covers are robust and long-lasting, but the solid cover edges out due to its heavy-duty nature. In terms of ease of use and maintenance, mesh covers win the day with their lightweight structure and lower maintenance needs.

For safety, both covers provide good protection, but solid covers offer a slight advantage as they prevent all debris from entering the pool. On the price front, solid covers tend to be costlier due to their superior features and durability.

Choosing the Right Pool Cover for Your Needs

The choice between a mesh and solid pool cover comes down to a combination of factors – your local climate, pool usage, maintenance preference, and budget. For instance, if you live in a place with heavy rainfall, a mesh cover might make more sense.

If your pool sees little use during off-seasons, a solid cover could be the ideal choice. Similarly, if you prefer low-maintenance solutions, opt for a mesh cover, but if your budget allows, a solid cover provides superior protection and durability. The key lies in balancing safety, convenience, and budget to match your personal needs and preferences.


Does the color of the pool cover matter?

Yes, it does. Darker covers can block more sunlight, which helps reduce algae growth. However, lighter covers might be more aesthetically pleasing and less noticeable.

What’s the lifespan of mesh and solid pool covers?

Both mesh and solid pool covers are durable and can last many years if properly maintained. On average, a mesh cover can last up to 15 years, while a solid cover might last around 7 to 11 years, depending on the quality and usage.

How should I clean my pool cover?

It’s essential to clean your pool cover before storing it. Remove any debris, then use a pool cover cleaner to get rid of stains and prevent mildew. Rinse it off and allow it to dry fully before storing it in a dry and cool place.

Can a pool cover be used as a winter cover?

Yes, both mesh and solid safety covers can be used as winter covers. They can withstand the weight of snow and keep debris out of the pool during the off-season.

Do I need a professional to install my pool cover?

While it’s possible to install a pool cover yourself, it can be a complex process. You might find it beneficial to hire a professional to ensure a secure and correct fit.

Can a solid pool cover withstand heavy rain?

Yes, but it will need a pump or drainage system to remove the collected water, which prevents sagging and potential damage to the cover.

How often should I replace my pool cover?

A well-maintained pool cover should last many years. However, signs of wear and tear like holes, fraying, or weakened straps could indicate that it’s time for a replacement.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *